An Agent-Based Model of Behavior in “Beauty Contest” Games
نویسندگان
چکیده
Recently, computer simulation, particularly agent-based modeling, has grown in popularity as a method to uncover macro patterns and developments that emerge from simple micro behavior. The present paper combines both techniques by using protocol analysis to uncover player strategies in an experiment and encoding those strategies in an agent-based computer simulation. In particular, Keynes’ (1936) beauty contest analogy is simulated in a number-guessing context. Several researchers have conducted experiments asking subjects to play “p-beauty contest games” in order to compare the experimental results with those predicted by the game-theoretic, deductive reasoning concept of iterated dominance. Our results are compared with those found experimentally in order to demonstrate the usefulness of a combining agent-based modeling with protocol analysis. JEL Classification: C15, E12
منابع مشابه
Agent-based modeling and experimental economics: exploring the behaviors behind the outcomes
A series of experiments was conducted on a single set of subjects to investigate learning and correlated responses. Altruism was inferred from an ultimatum game, learning was inferred by comparing the results of two successive beauty contest experiments, and iterative thinking was inferred from the beauty contest results. This paper presents a process for numerically modeling the experimental p...
متن کاملLevel-k reasoning in a generalized beauty contest
We study how the predictive power of level-k models changes as we perturb the classical beauty contest setting along two dimensions: the strength of the coordination motive and the information symmetry. We use a variation of the Morris and Shin (2002) model as the unified framework for our study, and find that the predictive power of level-k models varies considerably along these two dimensions...
متن کاملThe two-person beauty contest
We introduce a two-person beauty contest game with a unique Nash equilibrium that is identical to the game with many players. However, iterative reasoning is unnecessary in the two-person game as choosing zero is a weakly dominant strategy. Despite this “easier” solution concept, we find that a large majority of players do not choose zero. This is the case even with a sophisticated subject pool...
متن کاملHow do Multi-player Beauty Contest Games affect the Level of Reasoning in Subsequent Two Player games?
Behavioural economists have employed beauty contest games in order to test for agents’ depth of reasoning. In multi-player beauty contest games, fully rational players should all bid zero. In experiments, it is observed that average bids are consistently much greater than zero, which may reflect a population of players consisting of a combination of full and bounded rationality. In contrast, in...
متن کاملTesting Cognitive Hierarchy Theories of Beauty Contest Games
1 Summary Behavioral game theory experiments consistently reveal that individuals deviate from theoretically optimal (Nash equilibrium) strategies even in simple games. The α-beauty contest is among the simplest games that elicit such non-optimal behavior; accordingly, there is substantial interest in formally characterizing the observed play for this game. have proposed an intuitively appealin...
متن کامل